Our Dream List Of Castaways For ‘Australian Survivor: All Stars’

It’s time for a season of Australian Survivor: All Stars. My body is ready and thankfully so is Channel 10, as the network just confirmed a spin-off is coming in 2020.

This year’s season has proven what we already knew: Australian Survivor is sensational viewing with the right mix of people. An All Stars season will (hopefully) bring all the most iconic players together and I’m practically salivating just thinking about it.

We’ve gone through all the most memorable contestants to pick out who needs to do All Stars, only listing players from the newer seasons of Australian Survivor from 2016 to 2019 because let’s face it…we all forgot that the first two seasons ever happened.

(FYI: I haven’t included any past winners for a potential All Stars season. I know RuPaul’s Drag Race All Stars did it but it just doesn’t make sense to me.) 

Every Australian Survivor fave we reckon should score a spot on the All Stars season:

Henry Nicholson

I have to back my main man and Yogi Bear Henry because his hilarious stint on Survivor was a series standout. Will he go home with another idol? I hope so. Will he pretend to be a yoga teacher again? Who knows.

Locky Gilbert

We can’t bring Henry back without his partner-in-crime Locky. Not only did he slay the challenges but he’s easy on the eyes too. Like very easy.

Michelle Dougan

Yes, she was universally hated by most of the people on her tribe but every season needs a few villains and Michelle proved she gives zero fucks what people think of her.

A.K Knight

Speaking of villains, A.K didn’t make a lot of friends on his tribe initially but somehow managed to make important alliances and outstay some power players.

Phoebe Timmins

Everyone loves an underdog and Phoebe managed to find two immunity idols while in a tribe where she was very much on the outer. While she knew her days were numbered she hung on and we must stan.

Matt Tarrant

Known for being a strategist and a skilled mentalist, Matt proved to be a powerhouse in solving puzzles and keeping his alliance on side. It was smooth-sailing until Flick turned on him, which was his undoing.

Anneliese Wilson

If the purpose is to outwit, outplay and outlast than no tribe member has done this like Anneliese. She remained on the outer of every major alliance yet stayed in the game by gradually making allies along the way.

Luke Toki

Round 3? It would be rude not to!

Brooke Jowett

She was a massive physical threat and would have gotten a lot further in the game if her bestie, Flick, didn’t stab her in the back. I’m here for Brooke’s revenge.

Flick Egginton

Speaking of…I’d personally love to see Flick have to face Brooke again and I reckon they’d become straight-up enemies. I’d pay to see them face-off in a challenge.

Nick Iadanza

If you look up ‘snake’ in the dictionary I’m pretty sure you’ll meet an image of Nick. He was voted out early which, lucky for Nick, resulted in him changing tribes where he somehow slithered his way into one of the most powerful alliances. The boy’s got game.

Shonee Fairfax & Fenella McGowan

Never underestimate the power of two messy bitches who live for drama. These two besties were practically chained together during their time on Australian Survivor so I reckon they come back and play as one single castaway.

Benji Wilson

Going under the radar early in the game, Benji later emerged as a power player and one of the most strategic minds the series has seen. His strategy? Pretending to be everyone’s bestie while low-key running the entire game.

Pia Miranda

Speaking of low-key players, Pia went from almost being voted out at the first tribal council to pulling the strings for the entire champions tribe, all while playing along like she’s just some sweet and innocent actress. We see you.

Jarad Seng

Jarad played the game perfectly by anticipating that he would be overlooked and not considered a threat, so he slid his way through the competition. His game came undone as he faced a blindside just before merge. I’m personally here for Jarad’s vendetta.

Tegan Gasior

On the flipside, Tegan was treated as a threat from the beginning and had to struggle through every tribal council. She was eventually sent to exile beach and returned victorious. Such a boss.

Craig I’Ansen

Along with solid game players, a good season needs some hilarious characters to provide entertaining commentary so Craig HAS TO come back.

Samuel Hinton

Same goes for my astrophysicist bae…no, not Matt from The Bachelor. You never quite know what Sam will say but he’s always a laugh.

Tessa O’Halloran

Tessa proved to be a strategic force to be reckoned with and managed to stay in the game even after all her allies were sent home. She would go on to lead the charge to blindside Henry; a big move for the Survivor history books.

Moana Hope

There are some contestants that had the chance to show exactly how they could play but with Moana we barely scraped the surface. She elected to be sent home after suffering an illness and we reckon she deserves another shot.

Harry Hills

While it’s still early days on this year’s Australian Survivor, Harry has already proved to be a resilient player. He was almost being sent home a few weeks back but is somehow still in the game. He might be a bit of a messy player but he’s entertaining to watch.

Sarah Tilleke

Sarah’s social game was like no other and the model sailed through the early stages of the competition undetected, letting bigger personalities dig their own graves. The girl is a straight-up savage.

David Genat

Speaking of top models, y’all didn’t think I’d forget uber-villain David; he may not have won Australian Survivor but he won my heart. This guy was made for TV and could easily compete on the US season.

Shaun Hampson

As if we would waste the opportunity to not chuck Shaun in with David again. Am I already craving David Vs. Shaun: The Sequel? Abso-fucking-lutely.

I can envision them fighting it out the death on exile beach. Only one would return.

–

Okay, Network Ten! It’s up to you to make this happen. Please and thank you.

This article has been updated since it was originally published.